Publisher Lepmets & Nõges
Author Attorney Kristel Vaino
Revised at

The law protects the bully's right to education. Who protects the victim's?

School bullying is a deeply personal subject for me. I went to school in the 1990s, and my surname at the time was Jänes – Estonian for “hare”. That name, my glasses and always finishing last on the running track were enough to provide plenty of material for teasing. Nor was it any comfort to be told that children tease you because they like you or want your attention.

The most painful moments, however, did not always come from other children. When a teacher said in front of the class, “Well, Jänes, hop up to the blackboard”, it signaled to everyone that I was fair game for jokes. Eventually the situation became so unbearable that I changed schools. At my new school the bullying stopped, even though I was exactly the same child, with the same name and the same glasses. Changing schools helped, but it was not fair. The saddest part is that, decades later, it is still often the only solution that actually works: the bully stays, the bullied child leaves, and the problem is considered solved. But why should the child who was wronged be the one to leave, rather than the one who wronged them?

The numbers are not changing. So who is responsible?

According to the PISA 2025 survey, 27% of Estonian 15-year-olds experience bullying at least a few times a month, compared with an OECD average of 20%. In other words, more than one in four Estonian pupils is regularly exposed to bullying. This share has remained almost unchanged for eight years: the 2018, 2022 and 2025 PISA surveys all show the same picture, and other Estonian studies have recorded only minor fluctuations in recent years. According to the PISA bullying index, the situation has even deteriorated compared with 2018.[1] Over these eight years, programs, concepts and action plans have been drawn up, yet the numbers have not moved.

We talk about the causes of bullying, prevention programs, the shortage of support specialists and teachers’ workload. All these issues matter. In my view, however, we talk far too little about one question: what happens when the school knows about bullying, the parents have repeatedly asked for help, and the bullying continues?

As a lawyer, I encounter situations in which parents have been in contact with the school for weeks or even months. Meetings are held, emails are written, and the class teacher, the social pedagogue and the school management are involved. Sometimes a lawyer is invited to the meeting as well. On the surface, the problem is being dealt with. Yet the next morning the child goes back to the same classroom, where they are humiliated, pushed or excluded. Sometimes the bullied child is even advised to keep away from others, avoid conflicts or change their own behavior. In effect, the child is made responsible for avoiding situations they did not create. If the bullying continues, the problem has not been solved – no matter how many meetings have been held.

Bullying no longer ends when the school bell rings

When I was bullied, it ended with the school day. Home was a place where I could rest. Today’s children often have no such place. Bullying continues in the evening and at night online, and a photo or video can reach the entire class within minutes. In 2025, PISA measured cyberbullying for the first time: 9.9% of Estonian 15-year-olds had experienced it. Artificial intelligence has given bullies new tools. The Estonian media recently reported on a nine-year-old girl whose classmates had used AI to merge her face with that of a horse. For several days she did not want to go to school.[2] Images like this are easy to make and impossible to take back.

There is also a legal problem here. The Estonian Basic Schools and Upper Secondary Schools Act requires schools to ensure pupils’ safety while they are at school.[3] The word “bullying” does not appear in the Act at all, let alone cyberbullying. As a result, it often remains unclear whether classmates bullying a child in a group chat in the evening is a matter for the school. In my view it is, because the bully and the bullied child meet in the same classroom the next morning, and that is exactly where the consequences of the bullying play out. But this should not be left to each school’s own interpretation.

One practical piece of advice for parents: save messages, posts and screenshots. Without evidence, it is difficult to demand anything later, whether from the school or from the police.

The law requires schools to protect children, not merely to hold meetings

The Basic Schools and Upper Secondary Schools Act requires schools to ensure pupils’ mental and physical safety. Schools must take measures to prevent violence, provide supervision throughout the school day and respond to situations that threaten safety. These are not recommendations or expressions of goodwill. They are legal obligations.

This has also been confirmed by the European Court of Human Rights. In its 2024 judgment in Biba v. Albania, the Court stressed that an educational institution is in principle obliged to supervise pupils for the entire time they are in its care, including during breaks, and that the school’s responsibility for discipline extends to relations among pupils. In the Court’s view, Albania violated the Convention because the injured child did not receive effective protection at national level.[4]

This does not mean that a school can guarantee that no child will ever say anything unkind to another. It does mean, however, that where the school is aware of repeated bullying, it must act in substance rather than confine itself to formal steps. Schools have a range of support and disciplinary measures at their disposal. Where necessary, parents, support specialists and child protection services must be involved. Under the Child Protection Act, where a child’s well-being is at risk, teachers and support specialists are required to notify the local authority.[5] The bullying child may also need help, since under the same Act a child in need of assistance also includes a child whose behavior endangers the well-being of others.

The question, therefore, is not necessarily whether the bully has been punished enough, but whether the school has done everything reasonably necessary to stop the bullying. Too often a school’s response is judged by what the school has done, rather than by whether the child can once again go to school in the morning without fear.

The bully stays. The bullied child looks for a new school

In my view, this is one of the most painful contradictions in the Estonian school system. A pupil of compulsory school age cannot be removed from the school merely because their behavior endangers the safety of others or because they repeatedly breach the school rules. This is understandable: even a child who behaves badly has a constitutional right to education. But whose task is it, then, to ensure that the other children can learn safely?

The right to education, however, does not mean the right to study at this particular school and in this particular class. The European Court of Human Rights has explained that the right to education does not necessarily entail a right of access to a particular educational institution, and does not exclude disciplinary measures, including the temporary or permanent exclusion of a pupil from school, provided that the measure is proportionate. The assessment must take into account, among other things, whether the pupil’s education continues and the rights of third parties, such as other pupils.[6] Estonian law is stricter here than the Convention requires: a pupil of compulsory school age cannot be removed from the school, and a temporary ban on attending classes can be imposed for no more than ten school days per semester. I do not advocate removing bullies from school lightly. But in serious and long-running cases, the law should, as a last resort, make it possible for the bully to move to another school, rather than leaving this as the only solution available to the bullied child’s family.

In practice, the bully often stays in the same class while the bullied child’s parents start looking for a new school because they no longer see any other option. I fully understand these parents: when a child cries in the morning, is afraid to go to school or their mental health is deteriorating, a family cannot be expected to wait indefinitely for the school’s promises to be fulfilled.

The child has to leave behind their school, friends and familiar environment. Their daily journey to school may become considerably longer. The preferred new school may not have any places at all. And changing schools is no cure-all: school psychologist Karmen Maikalu has warned that the child may come away feeling that they ran away rather than received support and justice.[7]

Meanwhile, the child whose behavior caused the whole situation remains in their class. The most visible consequences of bullying are thus often borne by the one who was bullied, not by the one who did the bullying.

The Child Protection Act requires that a child’s best interests be a primary consideration in all decisions affecting the child.[8] I find it hard to see how it is in the bullied child’s interests to be the one who has to leave because the adults failed to keep them safe.

School bullying is not just “a matter between children”

At school, we sometimes call “bullying” behavior that we would take far more seriously outside school. If one person breaks another’s phone, we talk about compensation for damage. If someone is hit, we talk about violence. If a person is persistently humiliated or threatened, or false statements about them are knowingly spread, this may amount to a violation of their personality rights. Why should the same behavior become less serious simply because it happens in a school building?

Of course, children’s age and development must be considered, and not every conflict is bullying, nor is every incident an offence. But a child’s age does not cause harm to another legally irrelevant, nor does it relieve the school of responsibility. This is not about criminalizing children. It is about ensuring that a child’s rights and safety do not end at the school door.

Bullying starts with small things

Almost every long-running case of bullying started with something adults dismissed as trivial: a nickname, a “harmless” joke or a child being left out of a game. If there is no immediate reaction, children get the message that such behavior is acceptable.

A mother recently described how other children’s mockery of her fourth-grade daughter’s curls escalated within six months into kicking, harsh insults and having a lump of ice thrown at her. Repeated conversations with the bully and the bully’s parents did not help. The bullying stopped only when the head teacher intervened firmly and the police were involved – but by then the child was already in deep crisis. The same article also gives the opposite example: when the class teacher reacted immediately and the incident was discussed with the whole class the very next day, the bullying did not recur.[9]

The Child Protection Act does not only require a reaction, but also prevention: situations that put a child at risk must be noticed and addressed as early as possible.[10] Prevention is not one lecture a year or a program that is brought to life once a case has already arisen. Karmen Maikalu has stressed that dealing with bullying cannot be something that is done only when a specific case comes to light.[11] It means everyday work: adults who do not laugh along, who intervene at the very first derogatory nickname and who send the class a clear message.

The European Court of Human Rights has said that the state must always ensure zero tolerance for any violence or abuse in educational institutions – and in all circumstances.[12]

There must be no place for bullying anywhere – not in the classroom, the corridor, the group chat or the staff room.

Nor can an anti-bullying program serve as a shield for the school. Anti-bullying programs, including KiVa, are necessary and can be very effective. The problem arises when the existence of a program becomes, for the school, proof that everything necessary has been done: the team is in place, the conversations have been held, the case has been recorded and perhaps even marked as closed. Yet the child still says they are being bullied. A separate problem arises when the school must assess the conduct of its own staff. If a teacher ignored the bullying or has behaved disparagingly towards the child, a team made up of colleagues from the same school may not be able to provide a sufficiently independent assessment. Parents who have repeatedly informed the school of bullying should therefore have a clear and effective way to request an independent assessment of the school’s actions – not yet another internal meeting, but a substantive review of whether the school has fulfilled its legal obligations.

Nor should the school’s owner – in Estonia usually the local authority – settle for the head teacher’s assurance that the problem is being dealt with. It should demand answers to three questions: what has the school done to stop the bullying, why the measures taken have not worked, and what will be done differently so that the child can attend school safely?

Where is the Ministry?

Who should assess the school’s actions if neither the school nor its owner does so? The law does provide one answer. Under the Basic Schools and Upper Secondary Schools Act, the Ministry of Education and Research exercises administrative supervision over schools and their owners. The Ministry has the right to examine school documents, issue binding orders, inform parents and the public of any violations found, and impose penalty payments.[13]

But how often has the Ministry examined how a school has handled a specific bullying case? How many orders have been issued because a school failed to ensure a pupil’s mental safety? Do parents even know that they can turn to the Ministry? These are questions the Ministry should answer publicly.

The Ministry has emphasized that schools are autonomous and free to choose which anti-bullying program to use. In Finland, the KiVa program is used by 90% of schools; in Estonia, around 27% of schools have joined it.[14] The Ministry is preparing an updated concept for bullying-free education, and the draft national education and youth program promises to develop “clear principles for protecting children’s well-being and rights against bullying and violence”.[15] This is necessary. But the Ministry has had such a concept for years, and the proportion of bullied pupils has not changed.

Speaking recently to Estonian Public Broadcasting (ERR) about pupils who break school rules, a Ministry representative said that responsibility is clear at the level of law: above all, every person is responsible for their own behavior.[16] That is hard to dispute. But for a bullied child and their parents, the question is not who is responsible in general, but who steps in when the school and its owner do nothing. In practice, this too often remains unclear to the family.

Teachers’ heavy workload and the shortage of support specialists are serious problems. But they cannot become a universal excuse for why a child must endure repeated humiliation or violence.

A school should not be able to consider a bullying case resolved simply because the bullied child has left. That does not mean the bullying has stopped. It means the bullied child has left.

The bully must be held accountable, but the aim is not revenge. I do not believe that every bully should be removed from school. A child who bullies often needs help as well. Principles of restorative justice could be used more widely: the bully must understand the harm they have caused and take responsibility for their behavior. But a restorative approach does not mean sitting two children down at the same table and telling them to shake hands. Bullying is not a quarrel between two equal parties. The bullied child’s safety must come first, and mediation does not release the school from responsibility if it has failed to intervene for months.

What needs to change?

I changed schools, and it helped. But I do not want a child today, 30 years later, to have to escape in the same way – or for the bullying to follow them to their new school on their phone. Three things are needed. First, the law should state clearly that bullying, including cyberbullying, is the school’s business, and that a case cannot be considered resolved until it has been assessed whether the bullying has actually stopped. Second, in long-running cases parents must have a clear way to obtain an independent assessment of the school’s actions. Third, the Ministry should show publicly how it fulfils its supervisory duty in bullying cases.

A bullied child does not need thicker skin or advice to keep away from others. Still less should they be forced to change schools. They need adults who say: you do not have to leave. The bullying must stop. Because the solution to school bullying cannot be that the bully stays and the bullied child has to leave.

This article was originally published in the opinion section of Postimees on November 13, 2026.

[1] K.-L. Võhma. “Emme, kas ma olen napakas?” Eestis on koolikiusu rohkem kui teistes riikides [“Mum, am I weird?” There is more school bullying in Estonia than in other countries]. – Delfi, 2 October 2026 (PISA 2025 data, source: OECD). https://www.delfi.ee/artikkel/120614434/emme-kas-ma-olen-napakas-eestis-on-koolikiusu-rohkem-kui-teistes-riikides

[2] Cyberbullying data and description of the case: see note 1.

[3] Basic Schools and Upper Secondary Schools Act (Põhikooli- ja gümnaasiumiseadus, PGS), § 44(1).

[4] European Court of Human Rights, judgment of 7 May 2024, Biba v. Albania (application no. 24228/18), §§ 59–60 and 71–77. https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#{%22itemid%22:[%22001-233411%22]}

[5] Child Protection Act (Lastekaitseseadus, LasteKS), §§ 26, 27 and 27¹.

[6] European Court of Human Rights, judgment of 11 January 2011, Ali v. the United Kingdom (application no. 40385/06), §§ 54 and 58, https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#{%22itemid%22:[%22001-102675%22]}; PGS § 28(1)(4), § 58(3)(12) and § 58(8).

[7] I. I. Kert. “Laps soovis kiusu tõttu kooli vahetada, aga mina ei julgenud kiirustada. Kui seda aga tegime, paranes kõik” [“My child wanted to change schools because of bullying, but I didn’t dare rush. When we did, everything improved”]. – Pere ja Kodu (Delfi), 28 September 2025 (comment by school psychologist Karmen Maikalu). https://perejakodu.delfi.ee/artikkel/120405337/laps-soovis-kiusu-tottu-kooli-vahetada-aga-mina-ei-julgenud-kiirustada-kui-seda-aga-tegime-paranes-koik

[8] LasteKS § 21(1); UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, Article 3(1).

[9] I. I. Kert. “Neljandas klassis noriti mu tütart juuste pärast. Järgnesid jalaga löömine ja karmid väljendid.” Koolikiusu korral tuleb sekkuda kohe [“In fourth grade my daughter was teased about her hair. Kicking and harsh language followed.” In cases of school bullying, intervene immediately]. – Pere ja Kodu (Delfi), 31 March 2026. https://perejakodu.delfi.ee/artikkel/120448751/neljandas-klassis-noriti-mu-tutre-lokke-peagi-loodi-juba-jalaga-ning-soimati-karmide-valjenditega-kuidas-varakult-koolikius-lopetada

[10] LasteKS § 6(1); see also UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, Article 19(2).

[11] See note 1.

[12] ECtHR, Biba v. Albania (see note 4), § 67.

[13] PGS § 84(1), § 86 and § 87.

[14] KiVa data and the Ministry’s position: see note 1.

[15] Haridus- ja noorteprogramm 2027–2030 [Education and Youth Programme 2027–2030], draft of 1 October 2026, p. 7. https://www.fin.ee/sites/default/files/documents/2026-10/Haridus-%20ja%20noorteprogramm%202027-2030.pdf

[16] “Ministeerium: ennekõike vastutab pahandusi korraldava teismelise eest ta ise” [“Ministry: a teenager who causes trouble is primarily responsible for themselves”]. – ERR, 5 November 2026 (Jürgen Rakaselg, Head of the Inclusive Education Department, Ministry of Education and Research). https://www.err.ee/1610186128/ministeerium-ennekoike-vastutab-pahandusi-korraldava-teismelise-eest-ta-ise

13 +
years of experience
160 +
public recommendations
1000 +
real success stories

We are a top-rated law firm

The go-to partner for litigation!
Swedbank AS - Jüri Puust / Head of Litigation
Swedbank AS
Jüri Puust
Head of Litigation
Our cooperation with the lawyers Lepmets & Nõges has lasted for years and has been very successful so far. In our opinion, they offer the best quality and fastest service on the market at an extremely good price. Highly recommended!
Eesti Metsameister - Mart-Sander Mõts / Chairman of the Supervisory Board
Eesti Metsameister
Mart-Sander Mõts
Chairman of the Supervisory Board
I have used their legal advice and assistance on several occasions. Most recently, attorney-at-law Tauri Tigasson positively surprised me with his proactive approach, precise, and determined counseling, even pushing me to act more efficiently. It exceeded my unspoken expectations. Working with them has been a true pleasure.
Mikk Orglaan - Entrepreneur, investor
Mikk Orglaan
Entrepreneur, investor
Very high level, broad-minded, and reliable partner in legal matters. The sense of security is the most important thing I expect from legal assistance as a client, and this is the experience that the law firm Lepmets & Nõges always provides. Legal assistance should be like this – thank you for always being there!
Kaspar Eevald - Entrepreneur, mountaineer
Kaspar Eevald
Entrepreneur, mountaineer
I recently worked with the law firm Lepmets & Nõges, and their professionalism exceeded all expectations. Their lawyers are highly knowledgeable and skilled, offering clear advice and support at every step. I was impressed by how dedicated they were to the client's needs, always keeping me informed and answering all my questions. Excellent service and genuine care for the client make them a top-tier law firm. I highly recommend them!
Triin Tohv - Entrepreneur
Triin Tohv
Entrepreneur
My family and I are sincerely grateful to the Lepmets and Nõges bureau, whom we found through recommendations from acquaintances. A long and exhausting process had reached a dead end, but thanks to their professional assistance, expertise, resourcefulness, and, more importantly, understanding of the situation and humane attitude, we can now continue with our normal lives.
CK
Clyde Kull
Diplomat
There is a saying: “promise only what you can deliver. Then deliver more than you promise”. Lepmets & Nõges has always delivered more in our business relationship. Their knowledge, professionalism and talent is what I value most about them. I can honestly say I have always been 100% satisfied with their work.
AP
Alari Palumaa
Entrepreneur, investor
The solutions have always met and even exceeded our expectations. Pleasant attitude, friendliness and professionalism at each stage of the process. A reliable and necessary partner in all legal issues and litigations!
ToughWood Eesti - Kairo Tamm / CEO
ToughWood Eesti
Kairo Tamm
CEO
ALFA International - The Global Legal Network
Gasellfirma
Member of Estonian Chamber of Commerce and Industry
e-Residency Marketplace Member

ALFA International is a leading network of independent law firms, established in 1980. It is the largest legal network offering effective solutions worldwide. We are the only member of this network in the Baltics.

More about our partnership

Gazelles are rapidly growing companies that have increased their revenue and profit by over 50% in three years and created many new jobs. Less than 1% of Estonian companies are gazelles. We have won the Gazelle Company title three times.

The Estonian Chamber of Commerce and Industry is the largest and most influential organization representing entrepreneurs in Estonia, with 99 years of activity. The Chamber has over 3,500 members, whose contribution accounts for more than 40% of the net turnover and tax revenue of Estonian companies.

Lepmets & Nõges is a member of the e-Residency Marketplace. The platform brings together service providers who help e-residents establish and manage companies in Estonia. We provide legal assistance to e-residents with company formation and day-to-day business activities.

Protecting your interests in court, handling compliance and regulatory issues, or preparing transactions – we are a proactive legal partner for both business and personal matters