Property boundary: why the line on the cadastral map may not be final
Many people assume that the boundary of a property runs exactly where the cadastral map shows it. Problems often arise when some work needs to be done at the boundary, after which it turns out that the boundary does not run where the neighbours thought it did. Which is right, then: what is marked on the map, or the line on the ground that has been followed for longer? Legally, the answer is more interesting than one might think at first glance. We explain what a property boundary is, how a court determines it in the event of a dispute, and what happens if the boundary was misjudged during construction.
Can the cadastre and the land register be wrong?
The answer is simple: they can. Under the law, an immovable is a delimited part of the land surface, i.e. a plot of land, and the boundary of a registered immovable shows how far its ownership extends on the ground. The boundary is set when the cadastral unit is formed. The cadastral map and the coordinates of the boundary points are a description of that boundary, not the boundary itself. The Supreme Court has emphasised that when a cadastral unit is formed, the actual boundary relations on the ground are mapped. According to the court, this means that the map must describe the reality revealed by the survey, not that the actual boundaries of immovables are inevitably determined on the basis of the mapped boundaries. Cadastral data may be wrong for several reasons: a measurement error, inaccurate plan material, or an error in data conversion.
Nor are the land register data decisive in themselves, and they do not guarantee that the assumed boundary is fixed, for example on the argument that a different boundary would change the area of the property. The cadastral code, location and area entered in the land register are merely factual data, not land register entries in the sense of property law. Therefore, the presumption of correctness of the land register and the protection of good-faith acquisition do not apply to them. Such data are also not decisive as to the location of the boundary and cannot create ownership. In one case, a cadastral unit and registered immovable included part of the sea. The court found that the owner of the immovable had never owned that part, since a public water body cannot be privately owned and a cadastral entry cannot change that.
At the same time, relying on the factual situation does not mean that physical boundary markers always determine the boundary. Boundary markers may have been placed according to incorrect cadastral information. In that case, those markers and the boundary based on them are also wrong.
So how is a property boundary determined?
To begin with, the correctness of cadastral data may nevertheless be presumed in a boundary dispute. A presumption, however, means that it can be rebutted with suitable evidence and a different result reached. According to the Supreme Court, doubts about the correctness of the cadastre may arise, for example, where the boundary markers are located elsewhere than the boundary points used as the basis for forming the cadastral unit, or from how far the neighbours have actually possessed the land. Where there is doubt, all boundary data must be assessed together. It should be borne in mind that determining a boundary is not merely a technical surveying matter; it is an activity with its own purposes and principles.
The existence of cadastral data is not in itself sufficient to determine the boundary if other evidence indicates that the boundary has been mapped incorrectly. On the other hand, a later, more precise survey is not a sufficient basis for departing from an earlier boundary that was set on the ground, especially if that boundary has been followed for a long time.
If the boundary cannot be determined in any other way, under § 129 of the Law of Property Act the extent of possession, i.e. how the neighbours have actually used the land, is taken as the basis. If the extent of possession cannot be established either, each immovable receives an equal share of the disputed land. If the result of either method nevertheless contradicts the known data on the size of the immovable and other circumstances, the boundary is determined taking those data into account.
Building over the boundary: what next?
A common consequence of an unclear boundary is that a shed, driveway or fence partly extends onto the neighbour's land. Under § 148 of the Law of Property Act, the neighbour must tolerate a structure built over the boundary in good faith, but is entitled to demand that the builder pay periodic compensation or acquire the plot of land beneath the part of the structure (we have previously written about servitudes here). According to the Supreme Court, a builder acts in good faith only if they did not know and should not have known that they were building on someone else's land. When building near a boundary, the location of the boundary must be checked.
If the builder acted in bad faith or the neighbour objected to the construction in good time, the neighbour may demand removal of that part of the structure. In practice, a court has ordered an owner to remove a fence that extended a few tens of centimetres onto the neighbour's land. An expert examination established that the boundary marker installed when the cadastral unit was formed had survived but had become buried under the soil. The court found that the owner should have double-checked the location of the boundary point before building the fence. However, if the builder does check the boundary and, according to the data available to them, the structure is on their own land, they cannot be presumed to have acted in bad faith.
Be careful: verbal consent and good relations with your neighbour are not enough to avoid problems! The Supreme Court has held that a person who knowingly builds on the neighbour's land is not acting in good faith even if the neighbour gave consent. Such consent is an agreement between the neighbours under the law of obligations, which does not pass to a new owner of the property. Since such consent does not create a real right, the new owner does not have to tolerate a structure located within their boundary. If you want the use of the neighbour's land to continue after the property is sold, a servitude must be established and entered in the land register.
When should you be concerned?
Boundary disputes are not usually foreseeable; as a rule, people are not aware of potential problems. Nevertheless, there are warning signs: disagreements with the neighbour about the boundary, missing boundary markers, an unclear survey, or differences between actual use and what is marked on the map. In such a situation, it is worth clarifying the legal position before building anything near the boundary. Even a small procedure can have costly consequences.
The lawyers of Lepmets & Nõges law firm will help you establish how to determine the boundary in your situation, what evidence is relevant for this and what practical steps should be taken. We also assist with all other property and construction matters. If you have any questions, contact us.
We are a top-rated law firm
The go-to partner for litigation!
Head of Litigation
Our cooperation with the lawyers Lepmets & Nõges has lasted for years and has been very successful so far. In our opinion, they offer the best quality and fastest service on the market at an extremely good price. Highly recommended!
Chairman of the Supervisory Board
I have used their legal advice and assistance on several occasions. Most recently, attorney-at-law Tauri Tigasson positively surprised me with his proactive approach, precise, and determined counseling, even pushing me to act more efficiently. It exceeded my unspoken expectations. Working with them has been a true pleasure.
Very high level, broad-minded, and reliable partner in legal matters. The sense of security is the most important thing I expect from legal assistance as a client, and this is the experience that the law firm Lepmets & Nõges always provides. Legal assistance should be like this – thank you for always being there!
I recently worked with the law firm Lepmets & Nõges, and their professionalism exceeded all expectations. Their lawyers are highly knowledgeable and skilled, offering clear advice and support at every step. I was impressed by how dedicated they were to the client's needs, always keeping me informed and answering all my questions. Excellent service and genuine care for the client make them a top-tier law firm. I highly recommend them!
My family and I are sincerely grateful to the Lepmets and Nõges bureau, whom we found through recommendations from acquaintances. A long and exhausting process had reached a dead end, but thanks to their professional assistance, expertise, resourcefulness, and, more importantly, understanding of the situation and humane attitude, we can now continue with our normal lives.
There is a saying: “promise only what you can deliver. Then deliver more than you promise”. Lepmets & Nõges has always delivered more in our business relationship. Their knowledge, professionalism and talent is what I value most about them. I can honestly say I have always been 100% satisfied with their work.
The solutions have always met and even exceeded our expectations. Pleasant attitude, friendliness and professionalism at each stage of the process. A reliable and necessary partner in all legal issues and litigations!
CEO
ALFA International is a leading network of independent law firms, established in 1980. It is the largest legal network offering effective solutions worldwide. We are the only member of this network in the Baltics.
Gazelles are rapidly growing companies that have increased their revenue and profit by over 50% in three years and created many new jobs. Less than 1% of Estonian companies are gazelles. We have won the Gazelle Company title three times.
The Estonian Chamber of Commerce and Industry is the largest and most influential organization representing entrepreneurs in Estonia, with 99 years of activity. The Chamber has over 3,500 members, whose contribution accounts for more than 40% of the net turnover and tax revenue of Estonian companies.
Lepmets & Nõges is a member of the e-Residency Marketplace. The platform brings together service providers who help e-residents establish and manage companies in Estonia. We provide legal assistance to e-residents with company formation and day-to-day business activities.